UPDATE: Boardwalk Says Offer Still on Table Despite DCA Letter

Boardwalk still offering $800,000 over five years, despite state saying proposed bar ordinance "appears to be unlawful"

A Boardwalk offer to pay $800,000 over five years is "still on the table," despite that the state says a related town proposal "appears to be unlawful."

Marilou Halvorsen, Director of Marketing for Jenkinson's Boardwalk, said late Tuesday afternoon that Jenkinson's and Martell's are still jointly offering the payment, despite that the state Department of Community Affairs is questioning the legality of

"But if they pass a 12 o'clock bar closing, I'm sure it won't be," Halvorsen said.

"But our offer is still on the table because it's in everyone's best interest to come up with a resolution," she said.

Now it remains to be seen if a majority of the mayor and council decide tonight whether to accept the proposal, even as boardwalk businesses sue the town for the recently adopted parking plan.

"It appears to be unlawful" for Point Beach to impose extra fees on bars to stay open past midnight, according to a letter from the state Department of Community Affairs (DCA) to Mayor Vincent Barrella.

The letter (see first attached PDF), dated Monday, comes as the Point Beach Mayor and Borough Council are poised to vote tonight on two ordinances:

The meeting is scheduled for 7 p.m. at on New Jersey Avenue.

Barrella and the three councilmembers who have supported the ordinances have said the fees are being offered as an option to stay open past midnight, rather than the town mandating payment.

However, the letter from DCA Acting Commissioner Richard E. Constable III to Barrella does not draw a distinction between fees, related to the serving of alcohol, offered as an option, and those types of fees that are mandated as part of liquor license renewal fees.

The letter says the fees called for in the second ordinance would increase the liquor license renewal fees beyond the amount allowed by state law.

Constable acknowledges that municipalities are permitted to set the hours of operation for bars, but says that state law caps the amount of the liquor license renewal fees to $2,500 for retail consumption licenses and $188 for club licenses.

Regarding the retail licenses, "no ordinance shall be enacted which shall raise or lower fees to be charged for this license by more than 20 percent from that charged in the preceding license year of $500, whichever is lesser," Constable says in his letter.

"The conjunctive nature of the ordinances suggest that the Borough is looking to use its power to regulate closing times as a means to increase liquor license fees more than 10 times what would be permitted" under state statute, the letter continues.

"The Borough appears to be undertaking an unlawful effort to institute a fee that it has no power to institute," the letter states.

He goes on to remind the mayor that the DCA's Division of Local Government Services approves municipal budgets and notes that the town has already adopted its budget.

"If the Borough intends to includes these proposed fees in the 2013 budget, the Borough will need to share its legal theories as to why such a fee increase is lawful," Constable concludes. The letter is cc'd to Thomas H. Neff of the Division of Local Government Services.

The letter opens by saying that Constable is writing to Barrella in response to Barrella's questions, in a May 11 letter (see second attachment), about why the Division was questioning if the ordinance regarding fees was lawful.

Barrella said he will reserve any comments until tonight's meeting.

When asked about Constable's letter, Councilmember Bret Gordon said, "It's just one person's opinion."

Gordon said he has been in favor of both bar ordinances and viewed the one regarding fees as "a compromise."

"It's a measure to offset the high cost of policing the bars and for them to stay open until 2 a.m.," Gordon said.

Municipal Attorney Sean Gertner said that he is not commenting on Constable's letter at least until after discussing it with the mayor and council.

The concept of the fees viewed as an extension of liquor license renewal fees was expressed about a month ago by

In a letter, Livelli had said that the Division of Alcoholic Beverage Control (ABC) of the state Department of Law and Public Safety will not allow Point Beach to impose fees to serve beyond midnight because bars in town already pay the maximum fee of $2,500 allowed by ABC regulations for their liquor licenses.

Zachariah Hosseini, a spokesperson for ABC, said in a telephone interview with Patch at the time that municipalities have the right to regulate hours of operation and the serving of alcohol of establishments that have liquor licenses.

Regarding whether bars in town already pay the "maximum" fee for licenses, Hosseini said, "We don't regulate the market for liquor licenses. That's regulated by the town."

Regarding Livelli's assertion that ABC will not allow Point Beach to mandate that bars stop serving at midnight or pay a fee, Hosseini said, "We can't comment on the validity of that argument until it gets to the point that the town or the bars write to us asking for information or an opinion or it gets litigated."

The ABC would be the venue for such litigation, he added. He did not say the DCA would play a role in determining whether the municipality might be exceeding the maximum liquor license renewal fees by offering the fees as an option to stay open past midnight.

"Right now, this is still a local issue," Hosseini said. "This is not our business yet."

Many in Point Beach, when they hear about the DCA's involvement, will think back to the end of March when Gov. Christie was asked about the ongoing bar issues in the town while the . When Point Beach resident Marilyn Burke asked Christie about it, he said he would ask the DCA to review the matter.

Following that, Barrella said at a council meeting that after hearing about the governor's comment he called the DCA and he got the impression that officials there were going to let the municipal officials handle the issue as their own local matter.

Patch will update this story as more information becomes available.

Spooner May 16, 2012 at 02:57 AM
DaPoppa: for a change I agree with Ms Kelly...your not stating the facts(mis information) The Council did not make the $800K offer to the BW bars. Read the BW attorney letter on how the offer came about: under Jenkinsons photos at... http://pointpleasant.patch.com/articles/gas-letter
Jane Fisher May 16, 2012 at 01:04 PM
How can town officials enact a law claiming to do so in the name of a better quality of life for residents by closing bars and then propose a law that would nulify that by letting bar owners PAY to circumvent the new law??? That insults the residents and the bar owners.
whatdontyouget May 17, 2012 at 10:18 PM
I do agree with you that people are responsible for their own actions.. I could be mixed up with posts... I read a lot of post without responding most of the times. Did you ever post that bartenders are responsible by law for all the drunk drivers who get caught driving drunk? I don't agree to me it should always be the person who chooses to get in to the car and drive.
whatdontyouget May 18, 2012 at 12:12 AM
Marlene Blotto... You are something else.. A real piece of I can't say. What are you trying to say? Everyone in Lakewood schools are not what? Get a life.. Everyone knows you are a real nasty boy!
whatdontyouget May 18, 2012 at 12:19 AM
Beach_N8iv, What do you mean by a BENNY-come-lately crowd happy? There is a heck of a lot of residents that are originally from here or have been here for years that actually think these are great ideas. Don't blame the newbies if that is what you are trying to say... That is a down right lie. Maybe that is what you think, that is not true. The difference is most of the newbies are not hiding their views like the residents that are originally from here.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »