.

Group Against Belmar Boardwalk Buildings Creates Petition

A group of Belmar residents is hoping the council reconsiders its decision to build three boardwalk pavilions and put the choice instead in the hands of voters.

The organizers took to the Belmar boardwalk with clipboards looking for signatures to force the borough council to reconsider its plan and instead to add a referendum questions for residents to vote at the polls as to whether the buildings were wanted.

Belmar's previous boardwalk pavilions were destroyed in Hurricane Sandy, and council approved plans to move forward on three new buildings which would not just include hurricane-safety upgrades to the previous buildings, but would also differ in architecture. One would add a watch tower to the beachfront, another would be topped with a miniature golf course and a third would house banquet space.

Though Councilman Brian Magovern said the plans came after in-depth discussions with the community in months of beach reconstruction committee meetings, the residents organizing the petition said the matter needs to go before voters at large. The plans passed in July's council meeting, with Councilman Jim Bean as a dissenting vote.

The full statement from the group on Saturday:

BELMAR, NJ, August 3, 2013 – Armed with clipboards and the power of their convictions, 17 Belmar citizens took to the streets in search of signatures for a petition geared to let citizens weigh in on super structures proposed for the beach front. By the end of the week they were successful in collecting more than twice the number of signatures needed to require the mayor and council to either adopt the ordinance Requiring a Referendum Before Building Multi-Story Beachfront Pavilions, Except for Public Safety Uses, or to place the proposed ordinance on the ballot.

           

            Three new multi-story buildings, considerably larger than the former boardwalk pavilions, are proposed. “We’re concerned for three reasons,” said Noreen Dean, a Belmar resident and member of “Let the Citizens Decide” – the group behind the petition. “The buildings are overkill – far beyond what was here before Sandy and far beyond what a growing group of citizens feel is necessary. The town is already $52.6 million in debt and simply can’t afford to take on more. Ultimately this is going to have a major impact on the taxes paid by local property owners. People are also worried about how expanded commercial development will impact traffic, parking, noise levels, garbage and an extra burden to our police.”

 

             “The problem is, there is only one plan on the table – the mayor’s plan,” said Belmar resident Larry Reynolds. He went on to say, “The proposed plan includes things like a 53 foot high, 146 foot long, elevator building with a full catering kitchen, aquariums and a second floor 200-seat banquet hall that is the size of three houses. A second, two story building is planned for 8th Avenue.  It will approximately double the size of the original structure at that site and feature amenities like rooftop mini-golf and a 12-sink men’s room. I don't understand how a committee of seven people that are not from the affected neighborhoods had the unilateral right to change the complexion of these neighborhoods or make recommendations that will cost the town millions in additional costs.  It should be a community decision."

 

            Petitioners talked to hundreds of residents last week. According to Joy DeSanctis, the committee member coordinating the petition effort, “The overwhelming sentiment of the people we met was to keep costs down and rebuild based on the size of the structures that were there before the storm. But that was when people believed the mayor’s claim that FEMA and Beach Utility Fund would foot the bill. It now appears that claim is false.”

 

            “Based on the agenda for the Belmar Council meeting on August 7, the mayor is no longer implying that FEMA and the Beach Utility Fund will pay,” said Fred Marziano, also a member of the committee. “The mayor is introducing an ordinance authorizing the issuance of a $7,125,000 bond or note to finance the beachfront buildings. This now becomes a legal obligation of the taxpayers, not something somebody else is going to pay for. This amount represents an approximate $1,228 for every man, woman and child living in Belmar, and that’s without interest.”

           

            If the counsel ignores the petition and mounting resistance to the mayor’s plan and approves the bond ordinance, a second petition geared to get the bond on the ballot is ready to be launched.

 

            Kimberly Paterson, another committee member, summarized,  “Many taxpayers in this town are already strapped. If we’re going to add to that burden and force residents to pay the cost of rebuilding the boardwalk pavilions, we have the right to decide what will be constructed and to understand exactly what it will cost us before any plan moves forward.  It is morally and fiscally wrong for the mayor to take a $7,125,000 commitment into his own hands and out of the hands of the voters.  Let the people who pay have the final say.”

 



Tex August 05, 2013 at 07:43 AM
I have a feeling now that FEMA isn't paying the Mayor will have a change of opinion? This story is a perfect example of what is wrong in American. When the bill can be passed to others, it's spend, spend, spend. The whole nation will be like Detroit in 20 years.
ellen August 05, 2013 at 08:25 AM
I don't live in belmar but when I read this I thought I was reading a fairy tale there is no FEMA tree I think all of us who have been affected by sandy shld have learned that lesson!
patriotmfd August 05, 2013 at 08:37 AM
over kill....put back what was there.. local government should not be spending that kind of money on concession space
proud August 05, 2013 at 08:48 AM
New Jersey is already looking a lot like Detroit.
Bobby Edwards August 05, 2013 at 09:19 AM
I for one am proud of the work the Mayor has done for our town. This plan will not cost the taxpayers and I'm excited to see the new pavilions built. Keep up the good work Mayor Doherty, and please don't let a handful of cranks distract you!
Nicole August 05, 2013 at 09:30 AM
I think the new buildings would probably bring additional income, but I also agree that the township, not just the council, should have a final vote. The mayor needs to present his plan and show the townspeople how the investment would benefit them, and if they decide no, then that should be respected. On the other hand, I do not believe it is wise to build these structures. Another Sandy will come sooner or later, and it will destroy these spaces, and they will cost money to maintain, repair, and rebuild. Belmar should invest in dunes and vegetation to protect the town's assets instead and build mega structures off the beach. Buy some property on Ocean Ave. It would work just as well.
Dave Schneck August 05, 2013 at 10:30 AM
Just what we need......more traffic, parking problems, noise, litter, drunken hooligans and a mountain of debt.
Belmargirl August 05, 2013 at 11:44 AM
I think the title of this article is misleading. The group is not against boardwalk buildings. They are against the buildings the mayor wants.
Dame Bridgid August 05, 2013 at 03:24 PM
Keep It Simple. I understand replacing the buildings with ones equal to what was lost. A simple meeting room, a few low key restaurants, & small eclectic boutiques enhances the relaxed holiday atmosphere. Building a safety lookout for the beach patrol would be an asset too, if it is designed as a modest stand alone structure However; defeating the beach strolling charm of Belmar by super sizing these structures. & adding carnival fare like rooftop golf will just invite squalid development like the boardwalk hucksters shouting "A dollar for 3 tries!" or "One thin dime wins a toy!". Also, these grand designs will have to be repaired after large storms... Every time hurricane season & nor'easter season over lap & produce another superstorm the costs will be dire.
proud August 05, 2013 at 05:05 PM
Hi Dame. Long time no hear.
Mary Beth Clayton August 06, 2013 at 04:27 AM
Anyone who thinks taxpayers aren't footing the bill is is highly delusional. Where does the $ come from trees? FEMA is funded through taxpayer dollars. Most of all, lets not go much further with overdoing the dynamic of the beautiful historical Belmar. I feel those buildings should be replicated:)
Bobby Edwards August 06, 2013 at 11:14 AM
Joy DeSanctis? Is this the same woman who was convicted of kidnapping? http://www.nytimes.com/1996/11/03/nyregion/when-the-candidate-is-a-kidnapper.html
charlie August 07, 2013 at 09:32 AM
let's see, years ago the 16th ave mini golf, the 15th ave building and the 19th ave building were impacted by the sea.. The last storm impacted the 5th, 8th, 10th and 13th ave structures. I'm sure history will repeat itself. Will we be paying off bonds after the buildings are gone?
Beryl Cusic August 07, 2013 at 10:56 PM
Did Matt Doherty and the counsel do a good job right after Sandy?? yes. But we are now 9 months post Sandy and the time for us to blindly rubber stamp what the counsel can do in our name has come to an end. The emergency is over and now is the time for planning for the future. To think these pavilions will not cost the taxpayers a cent is foolish. The fact is that we are not guarantee that there will be any money from FEMA and the "Plan "B"" is we'll float a bond and pay that with revenue generated by sales of beach badges ( Oh and they will raise the price of the badges too), insures that we will be paying and our children and our grandchildren will all be paying for this decision, because the Mayor wants us to think of this as " like a mortgage". Now is the time to take a breath, do a cost analysis, including future maintenance, insurance and all the other expense of the buildings and give us a legitimate estimate and plan for paying and let us vote. My family and I have been in this town for 48 years and all I am asking is for a chance to vote on it before we jump in blindly.
Belmartian August 12, 2013 at 10:31 AM
Maybe if the designs of the buildings were more modest and looked more in the line of a traditional seashore home rather than a two story mini mall, the citizens would be more agreeable. There's got to be a compromise.

Boards

More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »